The Pastoralist Heuristic: Testing for Empirical Trait-Selection in Middle Nile Pastoralism — A Research Agenda Bridging Zooarchaeology, Archaeogenetics, and Biomolecular Method
Mohamed Gibbril1 · Yahia Fadl Tahir2
Abstract
The empirical logic of heredity — trait, transmission, selection, outcome — has a documented pre-formal history. Wood and Orel (2001) established this as a historiographical category for European livestock breeding. This paper asks whether Middle Nile pastoralism — cattle- and caprine-herding at the Third Cataract and Kerma — constitutes a genuine regional instance of this category, and concludes that the current evidentiary record cannot yet answer that question.
Four literatures describing the same corridor — zooarchaeology, archaeogenetics, modern population genomics, and biomolecular archaeology — have developed in near-total separation. Read together, they show that the ratio data usually cited as evidence of selection are confounded by at least three alternatives (drought-driven culling, wealth retention, ritual practice), and that species-level identification at Wadi Farja remains unresolved. Rather than assert a conclusion the evidence cannot support, the paper sets out a staged programme — geometric morphometrics, ZooMS, and dental-calculus proteomics — following published precedent from the same excavation population. No priority claim is made.
Keywords: Kerma · Wadi Farja · Third Cataract · zooarchaeology · ZooMS · palaeoproteomics · archaeogenetics · history of heredity
1 Gene Academy / SudaGene Consortium; Institute of Endemic Diseases, University of Khartoum (graduate programme). 2 Department of Archaeology, University of Khartoum.